,

Richmond Barthé’s Exodus and Dance, 1939, also known as Green Pastures: The Walls of Jericho, Brooklyn, New York

The wall does not try to stop you. It runs parallel to the path at the Kingsborough Houses, long and low, almost polite in how it occupies space. At first, it reads as texture more than image, concrete catching light, shallow lines interrupting an otherwise smooth plane. Then figures begin to separate from the surface. Arms. Heads. A knee bent forward. The wall does not announce itself all at once. It requires movement, your body matching its length, your pace determining how the narrative unfolds. Only by walking alongside it does Exodus and Dance begin to speak.

Set at the heart of the Kingsborough Houses campus in Crown Heights, Richmond Barthé’s eighty-foot-long concrete frieze occupies a space between architecture and sculpture. It is tall enough to meet the eye, shallow enough to remain tethered to the wall behind it, and expansive enough that it refuses a single vantage point. You don’t stand in front of it so much as move with it, its figures unfolding panel by panel as you walk.

Barthé completed Exodus and Dance in 1939 under the Works Progress Administration, originally for an amphitheater planned for Harlem River Houses that was never built. When the sculpture was relocated to Kingsborough Houses in 1941, it lost its intended performance setting but gained something else: daily life. Over decades, the wall became backdrop and boundary, meeting place and passage. Residents came to call it simply “the Wall,” folding it into the ordinary rhythms of the community.

At the far left, the procession begins not with weight but with gesture. A tall, standing figure, noticeably younger than the men behind him, extends one arm outward, palm open, indicating a direction beyond the wall. His body is upright and frontal, the gesture less dramatic than insistent. It reads not as command but as orientation, a body turned toward what comes next.

Behind him, older figures gather closely. Adults and a child press into a compact cluster, their bodies bound together by long drapery that falls in straight, vertical folds. One figure cradles a rounded bundle against the torso; another leans slightly inward, the weight of age and cloth pulling the group into a single mass. The child’s head sits lower, absorbed into the group rather than set apart. Movement is initiated not by force but by alignment: youth indicating direction, age carrying memory, a group poised to follow.

At the center of the wall, the rhythm loosens, and the procession reorients itself. A seated figure appears, legs extended, torso slightly hunched, hands held forward, his body turned away from the direction established earlier. Nearby, a kneeling figure leans inward, one knee grounded, the other bent, musculature sharply defined beneath the stone surface. Clothing shortens or disappears. Torsos emerge. The modeling tightens, revealing shoulders, ribs, and abdomen. This section reads as a pause, a hinge between burden and release, holding the viewer briefly in suspension.

Then the composition shifts again. On the right side of the frieze, bodies begin to repeat. A short sequence advances in near unison, hands lowered, palms open, weight shifting tentatively from foot to foot. One dancer becomes several, nearly identical in posture yet subtly varied in angle and alignment. Bare-chested figures lean into one another, hips angled, knees bent. Arms curve overhead or sweep across the torso. Simple, smooth wraps of cloth are secured low on the waist and flare outward, carved with shallow, rhythmic lines that ripple across the stone.

This is the Dance.

Here, repetition produces motion. The same figure appears again and again, like frames in a sequence, establishing a visual pulse across the wall. Each body echoes the next, creating cadence through variation. Faces turn sideways, chins lifted, eyes focused beyond the frame. Where the Exodus figures closed inward around what they carried, these bodies open outward. Space appears between limbs. The air seems to move.

Time behaves differently here. Movement is no longer linear but cyclical. The figures do not advance toward a destination; they turn, repeat, return. Barthé does not collapse the distance between Exodus and Dance, nor does he treat them as opposites. Instead, he has them exist together, holding endurance and celebration within the same sculptural field.

Throughout the frieze, Barthé balances naturalism and design. Faces are individualized but simplified. Hair is carved in repeating wave patterns, nearly graphic in their regularity. Musculature is present but restrained, felt rather than emphasized. The shallow relief keeps all figures close to the wall, prioritizing silhouette and rhythm over depth.

Light activates the surface. As daylight shifts, shadows gather in folds of cloth and beneath raised arms. Certain figures recede while others come forward. The wall is never visually static. It responds to time, weather, and movement around it.

The WPA-era belief that art should live among people was imperfect, often compromised, sometimes paternalistic, but here, it worked. Exodus and Dance does not hover above its surroundings or demand reverence. It remains part of the community, absorbed into daily routines. Children pass it without ceremony. Neighbors lean on it mid-conversation.

Barthé himself was conflicted about the relocation of the work, disappointed that it no longer stood before the performances he had envisioned. Yet at Kingsborough Houses, the sculpture has gained an unplanned, ongoing audience. The figures carved into the wall perform continuously, not for applause, but alongside lived experience.

Seen up close, Exodus and Dance does not separate belief from motion or labor from beauty. The figures carry, pause, bend, and rise without hierarchy, each action given the same sculptural care. Barthé does not offer an image of arrival. Instead, he attends to the ongoing work of movement itself, the way bodies adjust, hesitate, repeat, and continue. In a housing complex built to last, and altered by time like everything else, the wall remains a record of that persistence: not a monument to having arrived, but to the act of moving on.