Richard Hunt, I Have Been to the Mountaintop, 1977, Memphis, Tennessee

Someone had written “Fuck Memphis” across the sign welcoming visitors to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Reflection Park. Not once, but several times, the words squeezed into the white spaces between the park’s name and the list of organizations that helped pay for it. A few yards away, Martin Luther King Jr. smiled from enormous black-and-white photographs suspended beneath bright red canopies. Water arced into a shallow fountain. Red benches sat empty beneath the trees. And in the center of the park, Richard Hunt’s enormous rust-colored steel sculpture I Have Been to the Mountaintop rose from the pavement.

Dedicated in 1977, Hunt’s sculpture is not a conventional monument to King. There is no bronze portrait, recognizable body, raised fist, or heroic figure staring toward some distant horizon. Instead, Hunt built something closer to a landscape. Massive sheets of Cor-Ten steel have been cut, bent, curved, welded and stacked into a sprawling collection of peaks, ramps, wedges and arches. The sculpture rises and falls as it moves across the plaza, with one large central form climbing above the others. From a distance, the whole thing can resemble a small mountain range that has somehow pushed through the pavement.

Up close, that reading becomes much less certain. Hunt’s mountain refuses to remain a mountain.

Walk around it and one enormous curved section suddenly resembles a bowed head, its upper sheets of steel folding outward like a helmet or hood. From another angle, the sculpture begins to look animal-like, a gigantic creature crouched low against the ground. Move again and the illusion disappears. What seemed organic becomes architectural: ramps, walls and wedges gathered into something resembling a tiny Brutalist building. From the rear, long sloping planes stretch almost to the pavement, while narrow spaces open between the steel forms. Parts of it look like industrial machinery abandoned in the middle of downtown Memphis.

The steel helps maintain this uncertainty. Nearly fifty years outdoors have given its surfaces an extraordinary range of browns, reds, blacks and purples. Rust streaks down some planes. Sunlight flashes against others. Scratches and graffiti interrupt the oxidized surfaces. Nothing about it is pristine. Hunt made something that feels simultaneously manufactured and geological, as though these enormous pieces of Memphis industry have been compressed together until they became a mountain.

Only when you encounter one relatively flat plane does Hunt provide an explanation. Cut directly into the steel are the words: I HAVE BEEN TO THE MOUNTAINTOP.

King delivered his final speech in Memphis on April 3, 1968, while in the city supporting striking sanitation workers. He was assassinated the following day at the Lorraine Motel. Hunt’s title therefore operates differently here than it possibly could anywhere else. These words have not been transported to Memphis as memorial language. They originated here. The mountain is rooted in the city that gave the metaphor its terrible finality.

But Hunt does not illustrate King’s speech. There is no Promised Land waiting on the other side of the sculpture. There is barely even a clearly defined summit. The forms climb, collapse, bend and begin again. Some appear almost climbable themselves. The monument remains stubbornly attached to the ground.

Around Hunt’s abstraction, the rest of the park works very differently. Large historical photographs show King traveling, meeting people and standing alongside other civil rights leaders. He is almost always surrounded by others. Faces crowd around him in one image; in another, men pose beside an airplane. Elsewhere King stands beside Ralph Abernathy and another man in a room with a piano. The photographs restore everything Hunt removed: faces, bodies, clothing, places and historical specificity.

Walking through the park consequently means moving between two languages of memory. The photographs tell us who was there. Hunt attempts something harder to describe: what struggle might feel like.

The park itself is surprisingly bright. The photographic panels hang beneath swooping red fabric roofs, their color almost violently saturated against the blue Tennessee sky. Matching red benches punctuate the landscape. There are trees, shrubs, pale concrete, fountains and neatly laid paving stones. Meanwhile, Hunt’s dark steel mass sits heavily among it all. Beyond the park are office buildings, parking structures, traffic lights and passing cars. Memphis never disappears behind the monument.

Neither does the less orderly life of a city. The steel has been scratched and marked. The entrance sign is covered with obscenities. There was trash beneath one of the shelters. When I visited, someone had defecated on the sculpture. I photographed around it. There are things that tell you something about the life of a public monument and others that threaten to become the entire story.

What struck me more was how few people were there to see any of it.

My son and I essentially had the park to ourselves. The fountains ran. King looked out from the photographs. Hunt’s mountain sat beneath an enormous blue sky. Cars occasionally passed along the street, but nobody seemed particularly interested in stopping. The place felt quiet and oddly lonely, not abandoned exactly, but somehow outside the flow of the city around it.

Then we walked a block.

At the Lorraine Motel and the National Civil Rights Museum, everything changed. Tour buses were parked outside. Extended families moved together along the sidewalk. We passed what appeared to be a sorority reunion. People posed for photographs beneath the motel sign and stood looking toward Room 306. Groups gathered and dispersed, replaced almost immediately by others. King’s memory there was not quiet at all. It was communal, active, almost crowded.

The distance between these two places takes only a few minutes to walk, yet they seemed to occupy different worlds. One has become an international pilgrimage site, a place people travel to Memphis specifically to experience. Barely a block away sits a monumental sculpture by one of the most important American sculptors of the twentieth century, dedicated to the same man less than a decade after his murder, and we stood before it alone.

That loneliness changes the sculpture.

It would be easy to call I Have Been to the Mountaintop forgotten, but I’m not sure that is quite right. The surrounding park has clearly been invested in and cared for. The fountains still run. The grass is cut. The historical photographs remain installed. Hunt’s sculpture has not disappeared. Yet there is a difference between preservation and presence, between keeping a monument standing and keeping it alive within a city’s collective memory.

Perhaps that is why the condition of Hunt’s steel ultimately feels appropriate. This isn’t King preserved forever in bronze, safely elevated above us. Hunt gave Memphis something people could approach, touch, scratch, climb and walk through. Almost fifty years later, the city has left itself all over it.

At the Lorraine Motel, King’s absence draws the crowd. People look toward an empty balcony because they know precisely what happened there. Hunt offers no such certainty. His monument asks us to circle it, to negotiate its slopes and dead ends, and to keep looking as one form becomes another.

Hunt did not make a monument to a man who had reached the mountaintop. He made the difficult shape of getting there.