Kiki Smith and Deborah Gans restored rose window, 2010, Eldridge Street Synagogue, New York

The first thing you notice is the color.

Not just blue, but a whole sky of blue. Deep cobalt. Sapphire. Turquoise. Pale icy blue gathering near the center like light moving through clouds. From the floor of the sanctuary at the Eldridge Street Synagogue, the window reads less like a piece of architecture than something atmospheric, almost like a celestial body hovering inside the building rather than a surface fixed into the wall. Even when the sanctuary is dim it glows softly. As the sun strengthens throughout the morning, the blues brighten and shift, and the entire surface seems to breathe.

The window is perfectly circular, sixteen feet across, set high on the east wall above the ark. From the pews it presides over the sanctuary the way a moon presides over a landscape. Below it are carved wooden ark doors, brass lamps, chandeliers, and rows of benches worn smooth by generations of worshippers. Above it rise Moorish arches and ceilings painted with scattered gold stars. The window sits almost exactly between those worlds, between architecture and atmosphere, acting as a hinge between the physical room and the idea of sky.

Its structure is deceptively simple. Six bronze ribs sweep outward from a small central point, dividing the circle into six curved triangular sections. But the ribs do not radiate straight like spokes on a wheel. They bend and arc subtly, producing the sensation of rotation. The entire composition feels as if it is slowly turning, like a galaxy caught mid-spin.

At the center, where the ribs meet, sits a compact six-pointed Star of David. It is bright, dense, and jewel-like. Everything in the composition seems to flow outward from this point. Around it the glass begins to lighten, pale whites and faint yellows spreading outward before gradually deepening again into richer blues. By the time the color reaches the edges of the circle it has returned to darker cobalt and sapphire. The effect is subtle but powerful. The window reads almost like a cosmic bloom, light radiating outward into space.

Across this field drift hundreds of stars. Most are five-pointed stars, what the artist Kiki Smith once called “American stars.” They vary in size and color: bright white, pale yellow, gold, deep blue, and occasional darker stars that nearly disappear into the surface itself. From the floor they initially seem scattered randomly, as stars do in the night sky, but after a few moments a rhythm begins to emerge. The stars appear to swirl gently around the center, echoing the spiral movement formed by the ribs. From across the sanctuary, the entire window resolves into a luminous vortex revolving around a central star.

Up close, however, the surface becomes far more complex. The glass breaks apart into hundreds of irregular fragments that differ in thickness, texture, and density. Some are translucent and pale while others are saturated and heavy with color. Unlike traditional stained-glass windows, the composition is not divided by thick lead lines. Instead, the fragments are adhered to structural glass using a silicone lamination process refined by the studio that fabricated the work. Because of this, the seams often appear as thin lines of light rather than dark outlines.

The effect is remarkable. The glass reads less like a collection of pieces than a continuous luminous field. The stars seem suspended in open space rather than trapped within compartments. In some places the surface resembles rippling water; in others it looks like mist or drifting clouds. Morning light causes the pale center to blaze while afternoon light deepens the blues toward something heavier and more nocturnal. On cloudy days the stars emerge more clearly, like a night sky arriving earlier than expected.

The longer I stood beneath it, the more the sanctuary itself seemed to change. At first the room felt dim compared to the brightness of the window, but slowly my eyes adjusted. Details emerged from the shadows: painted ornament on the columns, small stained-glass stars embedded in side windows, tiny flecks of gold scattered across the ceiling. The creak of the old wooden floorboards echoed sharply in the otherwise quiet room. Occasionally the muffled sound of traffic drifted in from the Lower East Side below, reminding me that outside this extraordinary sanctuary people were hauling grocery carts down crowded sidewalks and delivery trucks were rattling past fruit markets and apartment buildings.

That contrast feels essential to the building itself.

The Eldridge Street Synagogue was built in 1887 by Eastern European Jewish immigrants living in one of the most crowded neighborhoods in the city. For people spending their lives in cramped tenements and exhausting garment factories, this sanctuary must have felt almost impossible in its scale and richness. Space, light, ornament, height — everything about the building pushes against the density and hardship of the surrounding neighborhood.

The window itself arrived much later. Smith created it in 2010 in collaboration with architect Deborah Gans, replacing a far more modest intervention: a grid of glass blocks installed in the 1940s after the congregation could no longer afford to repair the original stained glass.

By then the synagogue had already entered a long period of decline. As Jewish families moved outward from the Lower East Side into Brooklyn, Queens, and the suburbs, the congregation shrank. Maintenance slowed. Eventually the great sanctuary closed and worship moved downstairs to a smaller chapel. Birds entered through holes in the roof. Water damaged painted surfaces. The once dazzling sanctuary became a sleeping giant sitting quietly above the neighborhood.

The restoration that eventually revived the building took more than two decades. Decorative painting was conserved. Marbleized columns were repaired. Woodwork and stained glass were painstakingly restored. But when restorers confronted the east window, they faced a different kind of problem entirely.

No photographs or drawings of the original window survived.

To recreate it would have meant inventing a historical object that no longer existed. Leaving the glass blocks in place would have preserved a visible scar from the building’s decline. Instead, the museum chose a third option: commissioning a contemporary work that would respond to the architecture without pretending to belong to the nineteenth century.

It is a difficult balance, and one that contemporary additions to historic buildings rarely achieve. Too often new interventions either disappear timidly into the background or announce themselves so aggressively that they overwhelm the original structure. Smith and Gans managed something more delicate. Rather than imposing an entirely foreign visual language onto the synagogue, they studied the building carefully and extended ideas already present within it.

The ceilings already contained fields of stars. The architecture already relied on radiating forms, domes, circles, and geometric repetition. The new window gathers those elements together and transforms them into actual light. The stars painted across the ceiling become constellations suspended in glass. The central Star of David echoes symbols found throughout the sanctuary. Even the slow swirling motion of the bronze ribs mirrors the upward movement of the architecture surrounding it.

The result feels contemporary without feeling intrusive. The window does not imitate the nineteenth century, but neither does it attempt to dominate it. Instead, it participates in the building’s long history of transformation, decline, survival, and renewal.

Standing beneath it, the experience feels less like viewing an artwork than inhabiting an atmosphere. At certain moments, especially in the morning, the entire east wall begins to glow softly. The painted stars on the ceiling and the stars suspended inside the glass seem to merge visually. Architecture dissolves slightly into light. The sanctuary no longer feels fully enclosed. It begins to feel open somehow, as if the building itself has transformed into sky.

That transformation feels appropriate for this place.

More than a century after immigrants constructed this extraordinary sanctuary on the Lower East Side, after decades of deterioration and near abandonment, the building once again fills with light. The rose window does not erase the synagogue’s history or attempt to reconstruct a lost past. Instead, it acknowledges the complicated reality of the building’s survival.

Sometimes preservation means accepting absence. Sometimes renewal requires invention.

And sometimes, after decades of darkness and broken glass, light returns in the form of sixteen feet of blue sky.