
Several years ago, while I was curating a contemporary art museum in Atlanta, my friends at Institute 193 guest-curated an exhibition of sculptures by Kambel Smith. Smith is a Philadelphia-based artist who works somewhere between sculpture, architecture, and obsessive model-making, creating large-scale, intricately detailed cardboard versions of some of the world’s most recognizable buildings. We described the installation as a “metropolis in miniature.” Visitors marveled at the detail, especially after learning that Smith had never visited the buildings he recreated. He relied largely on photographs and Google Images, translating two-dimensional pictures into three-dimensional structures through a combination of observation and imagination.
I thought about Smith recently while returning to Saint Bernard Abbey, the first Benedictine monastery in Alabama.Nestled into a hillside behind the Abbey is one of the strangest and most remarkable art environments in the country: Ave Maria Grotto, the creation of Brother Joseph Zoetl, O.S.B. Across four acres, Zoetl constructed somewhere between 125 and 150 miniature buildings, shrines, monuments, and imaginary landscapes. Saint Peter’s Basilica is here. So is the Grotto of Lourdes. The missions of San Juan Capistrano, Carmel, and Santa Barbara appear alongside structures from Jerusalem, Germany, Italy, and places Zoetl knew only through photographs and postcards.

Together, they form something much larger than a collection of architectural models. Brother Joseph spent almost his entire adult life inside a Benedictine monastery in Cullman, Alabama, yet over several decades he managed to build the world around himself.
He was born in 1878 in Landshut, Bavaria. At fourteen, he met Father Gamelbert Brunner, O.S.B., who was recruiting candidates for the recently established Saint Bernard Abbey in Alabama. In January 1892, Zoetl joined a small group of recruits aboard an old steamer named the Suevia for the seventeen-day journey to the United States. He would spend the rest of his life at Saint Bernard.
A serious accident during his third year at the Abbey altered the course of that life. While helping raise a heavy bell into a belfry, a rope snapped. Zoetl suffered lasting injuries to his back and shoulders and eventually developed a pronounced curvature of the spine. He remained at Saint Bernard as a lay brother, beginning a life of devotion and labor that would continue for more than six decades.

For roughly thirty years, one of his primary responsibilities was running the Abbey’s powerhouse. The steam boiler required attention for as many as seventeen hours a day, an exhausting and monotonous job that nevertheless provided something valuable: long stretches of time in one place. Between tending the machinery, Brother Joseph began making things.
His first concrete structures appeared around 1918. Working with simple tools—hammers, pliers, brushes, scissors, forks, spoons—he began constructing miniature buildings associated with ancient Jerusalem and biblical Palestine. Many stood less than two feet tall. He called the collection “Little Jerusalem.”
People started coming to see them.

As the number of buildings and visitors increased, the Abbey eventually moved Brother Joseph’s growing creation to a permanent site along the bluff of an abandoned rock quarry. There he constructed its centerpiece, the twenty-seven-foot-high Ave Maria Grotto. Metal rods, railroad spikes, and chicken wire form its interior structure, while marble, seashells, colored glass, broken tile, and other discarded materials cover its surfaces. Even on a gray day, fragments catch the light. The ceiling seems to glitter with improvised stalactites.
Walking away from the Grotto and onto the pathway beyond it, the scale changes dramatically. Suddenly you are looking down at cities.
The path winds through more than a hundred tiny towers, churches, walls, bridges, monasteries, and monuments tucked among trees and shrubs. At first, I found myself trying to identify everything, treating the place almost like an architectural scavenger hunt. There is Saint Peter’s Basilica. There is the Pantheon. There is the Statue of Liberty. But eventually that impulse gives way to something else. You stop worrying quite so much about what each building represents and start looking at how Brother Joseph actually made them.

Broken dishes become decoration. Colored glass becomes stained glass. Concrete is pressed, carved, stacked, and embellished until it approximates stone. Shells become ornament. Bits of tile become elaborate facades. Everyday debris is transformed into architecture.
The earliest section is also among the most personal. Brother Joseph recreated buildings from Saint Bernard itself, including the powerhouse where he spent so much of his life. A miniature Statue of Liberty commemorates his American citizenship. Elsewhere, missions from the American South, Southwest, and West appear alongside churches from Alabama and Florida.
Then Cullman gives way to Rome. Saint Peter’s Basilica, the Vatican, the Pantheon, and Italian monasteries crowd together. Continue down the path, and Rome becomes Jerusalem. There are the Garden of Gethsemane, Mount Zion, Mount Tabor, and the Pool of Bethesda. Biblical geography, European architecture, American landmarks, and Brother Joseph’s own memories coexist within a few hundred feet of Alabama woods.


Some of my favorite structures occupy the strange territory between meticulous observation and improvisation. The Modern Cathedral of Tsitsikar in Manchuria, built by Swiss missionaries, rises like an elaborate confection. Nearby, a pyramid is covered with fragments of ceramic plates and cups broken in the Abbey commissary. These aren’t precise architectural models in the conventional sense. Their appeal comes partly from the places where accuracy gives way to intuition.
That distinction matters because Brother Joseph had seen almost none of the buildings he recreated.
Of all the structures represented at Ave Maria Grotto, he had reportedly encountered only about half a dozen in person: buildings from his childhood in Bavaria and those surrounding him at Saint Bernard. Everything else came to Cullman through photographs, printed descriptions, books, and especially postcards sent by admirers from around the world.Someone would mail Brother Joseph a flat image of a cathedral thousands of miles away, and he would figure out how its unseen sides might work. A photograph became a building. A postcard became a place.

You have to remind yourself of this while walking through the Grotto. You also have to remind yourself that Brother Joseph had no formal training in architecture or sculpture. He was working largely with concrete and whatever discarded material he could find around the monastery. What looks at first like an eccentric roadside attraction slowly reveals itself as the accumulated result of decades of sustained looking and making.
That may be what I find most moving about Ave Maria Grotto. Brother Joseph left Bavaria as a fourteen-year-old boy and spent virtually the rest of his life within the confines of Saint Bernard Abbey. His physical world became remarkably small: the powerhouse, the monastery, the quarry, the surrounding Alabama landscape.
His imaginative world became enormous.
Late in his life, during his sixtieth year as a lay monk, Brother Joseph was offered the opportunity to join a pilgrimage to holy sites in Europe. After decades spent constructing miniature versions of places he knew only from photographs and postcards, he finally had the chance to see some of them for himself.

He declined.
I keep returning to that detail. Brother Joseph’s life was defined by religious devotion and service, but Ave Maria Grotto seems to have provided another kind of freedom. Within the narrow geography of the monastery, he could travel anywhere. Rome could sit beside Jerusalem. Bavaria could exist a few steps from California. A broken dinner plate could become the facade of a cathedral.
It brings me back to Kambel Smith and those cardboard buildings I encountered years ago in Atlanta. The technology has changed- Google Images instead of postcards- but the imaginative leap remains remarkably similar. Both artists transformed flat images of distant architecture into physical places of their own.

Brother Joseph spent thirty years steadily constructing his version of a world he largely never saw. By the time someone finally offered to show him the places he had spent decades imagining, the distinction between seeing the world and making one seems almost beside the point.
He had already built a world of his own.


